How it works

A check reads a shop's own pages one time and looks up public facts about its web address. Each finding becomes a reason: one plain sentence, with the evidence behind it. The reasons together give a light.

What the lights mean

  • Green. We found no warning signs, and at least two good signs, one of them strong, or at least five good signs.

  • Amber. We found some warning signs, or too little to be sure.

  • Red. We found several strong warning signs.

  • No light. We couldn't check the shop. That says nothing about the shop itself.

Too little to be sure

Green needs at least two good signs, and one of them must be strong. There are two strong signs: the domain was registered 2 years ago or more and its record did not change in the last 6 months, or a seal's verifier lists the shop. Without a strong sign, green needs at least five good signs. When the other signs look good but we found no strong sign and fewer than five good signs, the light stays amber, and the result says so in a Note.

When no light shows

Sometimes we can't check a shop fully. It does not answer, it blocks automatic visits, or its homepage shows no shopfront. Or we read its pages, but they hold too little for most of our checks. Then we show no light, and the result says why. We still show the signs from the part we could check, but they are too few for a light. We never turn a missing answer into a low score.

What we look at

  • When the domain was registered

    We ask the domain registry for the registration date, where the registry publishes it. A domain registered 2 years ago or more is a good sign. When its record changed in the last 6 months, and the change is not the yearly renewal, it stays a good sign but is not a strong sign: the domain can have a new owner. A domain registered 1 to 2 years ago is a neutral sign: it counts neither for nor against the shop. A domain registered less than a year ago is a warning sign, and less than 90 days ago a strong warning sign.

  • A secure connection

    We look at whether the homepage comes over https. A homepage that comes only over plain http is a strong warning sign.

  • Contact details

    We look on the homepage for a link to a contact or imprint page and for an email address. A contact page and an email address on the shop's own domain are a good sign. A free-mail address, such as a Gmail address, is a warning sign. No contact page and no email address are a strong warning sign.

  • Payment methods

    We look on the homepage for the payment methods it names. Card, PayPal, TWINT, invoice and similar methods are a good sign. When the homepage names only bank transfer or crypto, that is a strong warning sign.

  • Policy pages

    We look for the shop's returns policy, terms and privacy policy, linked from the homepage. All three are a good sign. One or two missing are a warning sign. None is a strong warning sign.

  • Trust seals

    When the homepage shows a seal with a link, we ask the seal's verifier whether it lists the shop. A seal that the verifier confirms is a good sign. A seal image without a link counts neither way, because we can't confirm it.

  • Social media links

    We look for the links to social media on the homepage. We don't open the profiles, because the platforms don't allow automatic visits, so a link to a profile counts neither way. These are a warning sign: links that lead only to a platform's home page, or no social links at all.

  • A web address that imitates a brand

    We compare the web address with the addresses of known brands. A brand name in an address that is not the brand's own, or an address one letter away from a brand's address, is a warning sign.

  • The imprint address and the web address

    For web addresses that end in .ch, .li, .de or .at, we read the seller address in the shop's imprint, or on its contact page when there is no imprint. When the address is in another country than the web address's ending suggests, that is a warning sign. When it is in Switzerland, Liechtenstein, Germany or Austria, that is a small good sign. The ending is a signal of where a shop wants to seem to be, not proof of where it is. We skip return and warehouse addresses. When we could read only part of the page, we draw no conclusion.

  • The Swiss commercial register

    Many Swiss shops show their UID in the imprint or the page footer. The UID is the company's number in the commercial register, such as CHE-123.456.789. We look up that number in Zefix, the central index of the Swiss commercial register. An active company with the same name and address as on the shop's pages is a good sign. A company with another name or address is a warning sign. So is a company in liquidation, or a UID with no active company. A shop without a UID counts neither way, because a small sole trader need not register. The register's online data are not an official extract. Source: Zefix, Federal Commercial Registry Office (EHRA), via LINDAS.

What a check does not do

A check does not buy anything, log in or fill in forms. It does not judge products, prices or reviews. A result describes what we found on the date it shows. It is not a judgement about the people behind a shop.